However, it really serves as a very clear introduction to thomism, a topic that people spend years studying in university, and is only a refutation of the new atheism as a side effect. Winner of the 2008 book of the year in religion from foreword magazine and the only 2008 editors choice for religion from the american library associations booklist, the last superstition remains the most cogent and powerful refutation of the new atheism extent. The last superstition, a refutation of the new atheism, by edward feser, goes beyond the field of apologetics defense of the christian faith into philosophy. It is as if bill oreilly political commentator got hold of a thesaurus and decided to talk about tide goes in tide goes out. It is worthy of going slow and taking notes, if youre a nerd like me. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. When natural disasters occur, people say it is the mystery of gods will or gods providence, and we are not supposed to lean on our own understanding but to trust in him.
A refutation of the new atheism chapter 4 scholastic aptitude part 3. A refutation of the new atheism, that is not entirely the case. A refutation of the new atheism by edward feser 2010, paperback at the. Dec 10, 2010 edward fesers 2008 work the last superstition.
A common saying in philosophy is that you can read a book and enjoy it very much, even if you agree with not a word of it. The most prominent of the new atheists is richard dawkins. Download and read free online the last superstition. Sep 01, 2008 i am pleased to announce that my book the last superstition.
I am catholic but i see this interaction occur in various ways and i am always unsure how to respond to it. Read part i, part ii, part iii, part interlude, part iv, part v, part vi. The last superstition is the book i had been wanting, not because it is a tract against the new atheism, but because it summarizes the best arguments for an aristotelianthomist metaphysics in the face of modern objections. It is not just that secularists happen to reject and oppose religion. In the case of edward fesers the last superstition. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific. A refutation of the new atheism makes a philosophical argument for the classical aristotelianthomistic worldview over and against the materialist assumptions and scientistic prejudices of contemporary atheists such as richard dawkins, of. A refutation of the new atheism by feser, edward isbn. Here on this blog i will be critiquing fesers critique of new atheism. A refutation of the new atheism chapter 5 decent of the modernists part 1. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries.
This simply means if one does not see the bible to be anything more than fairy tales, it is futile to expect him to respect its authority. A refutation of the new atheism chapter 1 bad religion on almost every page of fesers book he seems to make about 10 ballsy points that i disagree with. A refutation of the new atheism is a provocative polemic that manages to skillfully do exactly what it sets out to do. A refutation of the new atheism by edward feser st. What do atheists who have read the last superstition. Augustines press, 2010 available on amazon us and amazon canada feser has the rare and enviable gift of making philosophical argument. The last superstition is thus required reading for any. A refutation of the new atheism by edward feser 2010, paperback at the best online prices at ebay. Dec 10, 2010 a common saying in philosophy is that you can read a book and enjoy it very much, even if you agree with not a word of it. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific account of the world has been worked out in such thorough and convincing. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or. I am pleased to announce that my book the last superstition.
There has instead been a conflict between two entirely philosophical. The last superstition by edward feser is an or recheck it out from the library which is what i did. Edward fesers the last superstition, a refutation of the new atheism it has been said that you cant teach an atheist with the bible. If you dont have much experience with philosophy andor metaphysics, the process of contemplating ideas that are foreign to you can take time to get used to. Last superstition, the a refutation of the new atheism feser, edward. This metaphysics is presented as it developed historically, beginning with the presocratics, on through plato and. But as edward feser shows in the last superstition, there is not, and never has been, any war between science and religion at all. Feser himself was an atheist who came to a belief in god through his studies in philosophyin particular, the works of certain secularists, who in spite of themselves, argued for. The last superstition the central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific account of the world has been worked out in such. Jun 30, 2017 this series originally began 5 august 2012. A refutation of the new atheism edward feser the central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that. A refutation of the new atheism makes a philosophical argument for the classical aristotelianthomistic worldview over and against the materialist assumptions and scientistic prejudices of contemporary atheists such as richard dawkins, of whom he is particularly critical. A refutation of the new atheism will be published this october by st.
The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific account of the world. Its a very meaty book that ive read at least four times, now, and will probably read again soon. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific account of the world has been worked out in such thorough and. There has instead been a conflict between two entirely philosophical worldviews. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Oct 11, 2019 18 17 16 15 14 12 library of congress cataloging in publication data feser, edward. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the last superstition. A refutation of the new atheism by edward feser on. His big scary weapon against new atheism is the old tired teleological argument. A refutation of the new atheism kindle edition by feser, edward. Indeed, feser points out that early modern philosophers like locke and hume failed to provide compelling critiques of the scholastic worldview a point substantiated by anthony kenny in his magisterial a new history of western philosophy oxford. Oct 06, 2012 the central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a war between science and religion, that religion has been steadily losing that war, and that at this point in human history a completely secular scientific account of the world. It makes me want to refute his book line by line like i sometimes do with christian apologists like william lane craig, but that would take me.
A refutation of the new atheism chapter 3 getting medieval feser starts chapter 3 lauding aquinas lifelong chastity and devotion to god, as if thats supposed to impress us. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawki. Edward feser but as edward feser shows in the last superstition, there is not, and never has been, any war between science and religion at all. What do atheists who have read the last superstition think. A refutation of the new atheism, written by a philosopher named edward feser, arrived a few. So the last superstition succeeds as a refutation of the new atheism. I enjoyed all of the book, but i strongly disagreed with the last quarter of the book.
377 425 1520 1163 873 1286 986 1427 907 948 1198 668 813 434 1400 925 444 898 51 450 418 325 122 949 1386 211 194 173 1488 1301 864 1433 1235 1109 257 291 785